Aggie's Kitchen

Pumpkin Butter Vinaigrette over Mixed Greens, Pepitas and Blue Cheese

A fall inspired Pumpkin Butter vinaigrette perfect to spoon over mixed greens, blue cheese and pepitas.

plate of mixed greens topped with pepitas and bleu cheese next to pumpkin butter vinaigrette

I definitely inherited the “no waste” mentality from my grandmother. She will find a way to use up every last drop of whatever you are about to throw away (for example…hand washing soap dispensers, I am constantly adding water to them and shaking them up to get those last few pumps before they get tossed – does anyone else do this?). She has always recycled everything – way before it was the “environmentally friendly” (and cool) thing to do…I don’t think she realizes how forward thinking she really is.

There was even a time when a few pairs of shoulder pads from some of my shirts from way-back-in-the-day (ugh) appeared as sewn together pot holders in our kitchen. True story.

I draw the line there.

plate of mixed greens topped with pepitas and bleu cheese next to pumpkin butter vinaigrette

Food is obviously something that shouldn’t be wasted, and I really try to stay mindful of that. I tend to make a lot of ‘clean out the fridge’ meals whether it be something like this roasted sausage and vegetable meal or soup. It makes me feel good to make meals like this, usually because they turn out to be extremely healthy but also because it lessens the guilt. Less guilt is always a good thing. 😉

jar of pumpkin pecan butter and bleu cheese

I used the remnants of a jar of Pumpkin Pecan Butter I brought home on my trip to Harry & David in October. This stuff is so good. With the help of some creative friends I got 3 good uses out of this one jar – I made Sandy’s Warm Pear Pumpkin Pecan Cake as well as a 2-ingredient fruit dip (1 cup pumpkin butter and 1 cream cheese bar) idea I got from Sommer that we munched on with some apple slices and crackers during Thanksgiving weekend.

My grandma would be happy to know that not a drop in the jar was wasted.


Pumpkin Butter Vinaigrette over Mixed Greens, Pepitas and Blue Cheese

  • Author: Aggie's Kitchen
  • Category: Salad

A fall inspired Pumpkin Butter vinaigrette perfect to spoon over mixed greens, blue cheese and pepitas.


For the vinaigrette:

  • leftover pumpkin butter (whatever is left in your jar, about a tablespoon or so)
  • 1/4 apple cider vinegar
  • 1/41/3 cup olive oil
  • 1/21 teaspoon honey, agave or applesauce, optional (my pumpkin butter had applesauce in the ingredients, adjust to your preferred level of sweetness)
  • good pinch salt and pepper

For the salad:

  • mixed salad greens
  • crumbled blue cheese
  • toasted pumpkin seeds (pepitas)


  1. For the vinaigrette: Add all ingredients into almost empty pumpkin butter jar. Seal lid and shake vigorously until well combined. Taste for seasoning (add more honey or agave for sweetness).
  2. Spoon over your favorite salad greens along with good crumbled blue cheese and toasted pumpkin seeds.
  3. Store the remainder in the refrigerator for 3-4 days.


I normally like a 50/50 ratio when it comes to oil and vinegar in my dressings, but feel free to add a little extra oil to your liking.

Nonna and Nonno

My cutie-patutie grandarents this past Thanksgiving. 🙂

Follow Aggie’s Kitchen’s board Homemade Salad Dressings on Pinterest.

Are you following me on Instagram, Twitter, Facebook and Pinterest? If you’d like to subscribe to Aggie’s Kitchen and have each post delivered straight to your e-mail box, then please add your email here. Happy cooking!

There are affiliate links in this post. I make small earnings through any purchases made through these links. Thank you for supporting Aggie’s Kitchen!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

23 comments on “Pumpkin Butter Vinaigrette over Mixed Greens, Pepitas and Blue Cheese”

  1. Def a creative, yummy salad. The only foods that go to waste around here are random condiments. Ill have to make more of an effort to save them

  2. Your going to make me order that pumpkin butter, because I have to make this now!

  3. Oh, this looks so good, Aggie. Love how creative you are! 🙂 And your darling grandparents … so precious!

  4. Of course I’m loving your latest salad, Aggie. Beautiful!!

  5. This is so brilliant, Aggie, I love it. The perfect fall salad. You are the queen of amazing salads!

  6. I get it – I am totally that person who pours a couple ounces of hot water into the empty pasta sauce jar before shaking it up and getting the last bits of sauce out. My husband always teases me a bit for it. Glad to know I am not alone 😉
    Your grandparents are adorable!

  7. Sooo good!! I tried this vinaigrette tonight on our salad (along with pumpkin seeds and orange-infused cranberries) and it was sooo delicious! Thank you so much!

  8. Pingback: Elf4Health Challenge – Pumpkin Butter Vinaigrette | Planetmarsz

  9. Oh my love the pic of your grandparents. and Hey You are a genius with this dressing lady. drool.

  10. The photo of your grandparents made me smile! Grandparents can really be a special part of our lives! The salad, oh this salad, I think it is speaking to me! I need some of that pumpkin butter soon!

  11. This is a great idea and a yummy salad. I love the photo of your grandparents – so cute.

  12. That salad looks great and I bet the pumpkin butter was delish! Love the story of your grandma

  13. Okay, I love the shoulder pad story. Too funny! This vinaigrette is brilliant. I happen to have a container of Harry & David’s pumpkin butter and I am definitely making this. 🙂

  14. With all the heavy food this time of year, I need a good salad like this!

  15. Pumpkin vinaigrette is a great idea!! I love making my own dressings so I am def. adding that to the list! I actually have some left over that I need to use so it might be a perfect change to test this recipe out.

  16. Your grandparents are so cute!! What a great recipe, Aggie!!

  17. Useful recipe for all pumpkin lovers, but always remind that we should use vinegar very carefully in our food items it can be harmful for our internal body parts.

  18. Like you, I learned from my mom and grandmother to be frugal as well. I find it very difficult to throw anything away until there’s no hope of salvaging anything else from it. I even add water to my laundry detergent bottle to get one last small wash. Delicious looking salad!

  19. What a genius idea to use this jar!! My mom makes homemade apple butter – thinking the same thing!!

  20. This looks absolutely delicious! I’m going to have to try the Pumpkin Butter, because using it in the viniagrette sounds divine! YUM! Thanks for the great idea!

  21. We love this simple yet irresistable salad! The classic yet delicious blend of greens, pepitas, and blue cheese is enhanced by the unique vinaigrette! A great blue cheese option is the Sargento Crumbled Blue Cheese. Perfect for salads and wraps, this blue cheese also tastes great with burgers and grilled sandwiches.